As far as sports documentaries go, it's pretty middle of the road. I don't feel there's enough story here to warrant an hour and 40 minute runtime. However, the worst part is the misleading title. I guess they were trying to be cute, but the story has nothing to do with identity theft. As someone that remembered Mustain and didn't know what happened to him, I was expecting a somewhat interesting story about him, but it was pretty much just a retelling of his high school and college career that's not terribly uncommon. I suppose if you're from the area or into Arkansas football, you get more enjoyment out of it, but for a sports documentary, there just isn't enough of a compelling story here.