★ 7 / 10
Good post-war whodunit
guy-bellinger
« Seul dans la nuit » (Alone in the Night), recently rediscovered, thanks in particular to its 4K restoration, is a good little whodunit from the immediate…
« Seul dans la nuit » (Alone in the Night), recently rediscovered, thanks in particular to its 4K restoration, is a good little whodunit from the immediate post-war period. The movie maker, Christian Stengel, unknown to film historians, is an alert storyteller, skilled technician and good actor's director. He may not be a great stylist, but he knows how to make an effective film that's a pleasure to follow.
The basic situation is hardly original (a C. I. D. Investigation into a ladystrangler), but the way the subject is handled is more so. Without ever losing the thread of the investigation, the director, skilfully illustrating the script by the even more obscure Jacqueline and Yves Boisyvon, mixes genres with a certain ease: detective story (as already mentioned), comedy (thanks to Marc-Gilbert Sauvajon's sharp pen and actors who know how to bring out the best in his lines), musical film (the hero, Jacques Sartory, is a crooner), a documentary aspect on show business on a daily basis (meetings with the artistic team, organization of tours, answers to fan mail on the radio and even - in 1945! - a concert filmed live in an auditorium on television).
Add to this a fine job by cinematographer Christian Matras (especially in the night-time sequences) and, of course, a remarkable cast bringing to life a varied range of characters: (Bernard Blier, still wiry and shy lover), Sophie Desmarets (vivacious, assertive, not at all a trophy wife), Louis Salou (as an eccentric, clinging witness), and so on. Among them, Jacques Morel's little-known talent as an impersonator stands out here, as Fernandel, he's exceptional.
The most dated aspect of this film is Sartory's singing. Jacques Pills (Edith Piaf's future husband), almost in his own role, no longer appeals to today's ears, and the director could (and should) have refrained from filming him cooing a song three times - and in extenso. On the other hand, Pills turns out to be an excellent actor, subtly revealing his state of mind as a public idol whose pedestal suddenly wobbles.
Apart from this minor flaw, the film is constantly entertaining and intriguing. At one point, it does even more and better. I'm referring to the extraordinary sequence of Dalbret (Jean Davy)'s declamation: the man, disfigured after an accident, plays Lorenzaccio in a disused theater. He no longer looks the part, but his passion hasn't left him. It's a moment of profound emotion, not only for the characters played by Blier, Desmarets and Salou, but also for the viewer.
The scene precedes a finale that, while not reaching these heights, is not without its merits. Alone in the night, the petrolhead Thérèse (Sophie Desmarets) shows herself to be more fragile, more ambiguous.
A good quality film. Recommended.
Read full review
★ 6 / 10
Overrated
adverts
I wanted to review this film and then read the first reviewer's comments...they expressed exactly what I was planning to write: This is a thriller that doesn't…
I wanted to review this film and then read the first reviewer's comments...they expressed exactly what I was planning to write:
This is a thriller that doesn't generate any thrills.
It's also a whodunit that simply isn't that interesting because it's fairly obvious who IS NOT the killer and the film only comes up with one other possible option. I feel like this could have been a 1hr bottom of the bill picture and fared just as well. The acting is good and dialogue is fine, but not much happens in 100 minutes.
I managed to purchase a pristine print with excellent subtitles because I could not find it anywhere else -- not sure if it was woth it.
Read full review
6.9/10
167
•••
Muchas gracias, solamente lamentar que no haya opción en 1080p con un poco más de tamaño, como alternativa para compañeros que quieran más calidad de imagen. Gracias de nuevo!!!!!!