★ 9 / 10
A Hypnotic Masterpiece of Silent Arthouse Cinema
Garin Nugroho's "Samsara" is a bold, hypnotic triumph that proves Indonesian arthouse cinema is operating on an entirely different level. By stripping away all…
Garin Nugroho's "Samsara" is a bold, hypnotic triumph that proves Indonesian arthouse cinema is operating on an entirely different level. By stripping away all dialogue and relying purely on striking black-and-white cinematography alongside the incredibly expressive physical performances of Ario Bayu and Juliet Widyasari Burnett, the film forces you to absorb its tragic Balinese folklore through pure sensory immersion. What elevates this beyond a simple morality tale of greed and dark rituals is the breathtaking, experimental score-a masterful collision of traditional gamelan and pulsating electronic beats that completely envelopes the audience and acts as the true voice of the film. It is a wildly audacious, surreal, and deeply atmospheric cinematic experience that demands patience but rewards you with absolute audiovisual poetry.
Read full review
★ 9 / 10
I wish I could watch this in the cinema?
D_RIVIEW
Samsara presents itself as a film with a highly experimental concept. It explores several themes, such as love, greed, fate, excessive ambition, and…
Samsara presents itself as a film with a highly experimental concept. It explores several themes, such as love, greed, fate, excessive ambition, and consequences. At a time when Indonesian films are largely dominated by formulaic works, but Garin Nugroho delivers a conceptually bold film, and it's a silent film. Here, we are presented with a story that is essentially simple, yet wrapped in Balinese cultural symbolism that makes it unique, increasingly engaging, and layered. In terms of drama, personally, it may not be the type that is overtly emotional, but it still feels deeply resonant. The characterization is fairly unique, with backgrounds that are intriguing to explore further. The pacing may not suit everyone, but it works well enough to keep us continuously focused on the film. Visually, it is absolutely top notch, with distinctive camera angles and staging that truly deserve so much appreciation. Each scene feels long, yet never dragging, instead, it genuinely showcases the artistry in greater detail. The technical effects strongly enhance the mystical and magical atmosphere. The production design is crafted not only to be aesthetically pleasing but also authentic to the Balinese setting of the 1930s. The score plays a crucial role, blending beautifully listenable traditional music with electronic elements that support the emotional moments, without ever diminishing the presence of the traditional melodies. We can read the performances purely through facial expressions and gestures, and they are executed remarkably well. Overall, this may not be a film for everyone, but it is nonetheless a must-watch.I give this 9.1/10.
Read full review
★ 7 / 10
Visually Powerful, Mythically Simplified
bafreux
Samsara, directed by Garin Nugroho, is a strikingly bold aesthetic achievement. Shot in black and white and presented as a silent film, it relies on gesture…
Samsara, directed by Garin Nugroho, is a strikingly bold aesthetic achievement. Shot in black and white and presented as a silent film, it relies on gesture, composition, and atmosphere rather than dialogue. The theatrical staging feels deliberate and sculptural, almost like watching moving temple reliefs or wayang-inspired performance. Visually, the film is disciplined, elegant, and often mesmerizing.The music stands out as well. The fusion of experimental electronic textures with traditional gamelan elements creates a powerful and immersive soundscape. Whether one fully embraces the blend or not, it is undeniably daring and thoughtfully constructed.The silent format is one of the film's strongest choices. It sharpens attention toward body language and spatial tension, allowing expression and movement to carry emotional weight. In purely cinematic terms, the film succeeds impressively.However, narratively it is less satisfying. Compared to Nugroho's earlier Opera Jawa, which could feel too complex for viewers unfamiliar with Javanese mythology, Samsara leans toward over-clarity. Textual framing elements guide interpretation so directly that mystery and surprise are reduced. The myth becomes more moral tale than lived cosmology.While rooted in Indonesian traditions that are philosophically non-dual and layered, the dramatic arc feels more binary than the source cosmology suggests. Moments of symbolic nuance are present, but the overall structure simplifies what could have been more metaphysically ambiguous.The appearance of Semar - a central spiritual figure in Javanese thought - is visually intriguing, yet his deeper significance is left largely unexplored. For international audiences especially, this may feel like a missed opportunity for greater philosophical depth.As visual art, Samsara is impressive and original. As mythic storytelling, it feels more controlled and didactic than mystical.A beautiful and daring film - though one that resonates more through its form than its metaphysics.Visually 8,5
Music 8
Narratively 5-6.
Read full review
•••
Base on Balinese Hindu Mythology