★ 6 / 10
According to novelist Bernard MacLaverty, this took almost
CinemaSerf
According to novelist Bernard MacLaverty, this took almost nine years from contract to can and had quite a bumpy ride along the way via writers' strikes and…
According to novelist Bernard MacLaverty, this took almost nine years from contract to can and had quite a bumpy ride along the way via writers' strikes and COVID before they managed to recruit the services of Lesley Manville and Ciarán Hinds and take us all to Amsterdam. We know from the opening scenes that both hail from Belfast and that she, whilst pregnant, was caught up in the troubles necessitating their relocation to Glasgow. Now married for thirty-odds years, they live separate lives with “Stella” fairly devout with her faith and “Gerry” with his Scotch. It’s all amicable enough, though, and so for Christmas she arranges their trip. Off they go and as they explore the city we slowly learn a little more about what has driven them to their current situation and also of just what she proposes to do to fill what she considers to be the hole in her life. It’s a bit of a sandwich of a film this. It starts intriguingly and it finishes with something by way of thoughtful honesty but the filling is really anything but. It meanders along with a lot of establishing photography and him sneaking the odd dram (or five) but we don’t really do enough by way of developing their characterisations. After their lengthy marriage it seems that neither really know the other, nor what makes them tick - but is that really plausible? Their respective, and conflicting, approaches to her Catholicism seem to be a part of the basis for their diffidence, but again after festering for decades that isn’t really developed beyond the obvioulsy huge amounts of guilt that have dogged her since her escape from the initial tragedy from her youth. There are interesting threads running throughout the story, and some of the writing is both humorous and strikingly powerful, but despite a considered effort from both this just doesn’t really deal with the issues it raises beyond the superficial. It’s a fine watch for the telly but as piece of cinema, it's a little too incomplete for me.
Read full review
★ 7 / 10
It’s becoming increasingly rare these days that movies
Brent Marchant
It’s becoming increasingly rare these days that movies present stories with insightful, contemplative narratives, despite the fact that we probably need…
It’s becoming increasingly rare these days that movies present stories with insightful, contemplative narratives, despite the fact that we probably need pictures like this now more than ever. However, viewers looking for films that provide them with profound food for thought should seriously consider screening this latest offering from director Polly Findlay. Based on the acclaimed 2017 novel of the same name by author Bernard MacLaverty, the film tells the story of Stella (Lesley Manville) and Gerry (Ciarán Hinds), a long-married couple who fled “the Troubles” in Belfast, Northern Ireland for the safety and security of a new life in Glasgow, Scotland, where they’ve now lived for many years. However, over time, their marriage has slowly and quietly eroded into a stale relationship. While they appear to still love one another, there’s not much else sustaining their increasingly tenuous connection. It’s a source of considerable concern for Stella, who wants greater fulfillment out of life, particularly on a spiritual level, a subject in which Gerry shows essentially no interest. But Stella isn’t ready to give up just yet; so, to try and restore the viability of their bond, she surprises Gerry with a Christmas gift in the form of a trip to Amsterdam, a journey that she sees as a chance for “an adventure” to help rejuvenate their marriage. But, as soon becomes apparent, Stella has another reason for making the trip, one aimed at satisfying her own personal curiosity and personal well-being but that also potentially places the future of the couple’s already-shaky relationship in jeopardy. The journey thus gives husband and wife pause to evaluate what may lie ahead for them, prompting deep questions about the nature and quality of their partnership, reconciling feelings about ghosts from their past, examining personal lifestyle choices, and taking stock of “big picture” perspectives on life and their respective places in the Universe. In turn, this inadvertent soul-searching exercise unearths some surprising revelations, especially when it comes to bursting long-held bubbles in their individual belief systems. Who would have thought that a simple getaway could raise so many issues with such pervasively profound implications? Nevertheless, such are the unexpected circumstances that Stella and Gerry find themselves in, leaving them to wonder whether they’ll be able to withstand their challenges and stay together or find themselves irrevocably changed. “Midwinter Break” employs a deftly constructed storytelling approach in addressing these questions, one that’s layered, nuanced and eminently thoughtful on many levels. It’s also the kind of picture that requires close, careful, engaged viewing; without that, audience members – like the protagonists themselves – might easily miss the forest for the trees, one of the chief objectives this picture seeks to help us overcome. This emerges through the carefully crafted writing and the superb performances of the two leads, both of whom are clearly at the top of their game here. It’s also a gorgeous cinematic showcase for the picturesque city that serves as the story’s backdrop but without turning into a veiled travelogue. Admittedly, there are some pacing issues early on and some occasionally awkward, overly “mechanical” sequences (again at the outset) as the film seeks to find a firm footing for itself. But one could argue that these shortcomings are reflective of the puzzling and unanticipated introspective process in which the principals are about to enter. Still, those looking to be fed by this release’s ample, meaningful subject matter will likely find themselves nicely satisfied by film’s end. This offering makes for perfect midwinter viewing, a picture that has come along at just the right time to provide us with our own restorative midwinter breaks, regardless of whether we’re talking in literal or metaphorical terms. And who knows what we might take away from the experience? It could prove life-changing – or not – depending on what we each need and what we get out of it ‒ much like life itself.
Read full review
★ 7 / 10
Not really my type of movie but I
Leno
Not really my type of movie but I was lucky to get a free ticket from letterboxd so I watched it. The movie follows the series of events that unfold after an…
Not really my type of movie but I was lucky to get a free ticket from letterboxd so I watched it.
The movie follows the series of events that unfold after an old couple with a monotonous life go to vacations on Amsterdam after a seemingly impromptu decision of the wife to bring some change to life.
Turns out a traumatic event from many years ago is surfacing from her mind and has relation with the trip, which can bring grievous consequences to their relationship.
Well shot and well-acted, a great movie if you enjoy slow-paced dramas.
Read full review
63%
TOMATOMETER
· 52 reviews
42%
AUDIENCE
· 50 ratings
6.0/10
1.8K
•••
I say sh*t one time and that's much Xd boi get from under that rock. Your on a pira*e we*site!