IMDb reviews From IMDb
★ 1 / 10
To be blunt, I really dislike arthouse films
Brent Marchant
To be blunt, I really dislike arthouse films that give the genre a bad name, yet writer-director Ramon Zürcher’s third feature outing regrettably does just…
To be blunt, I really dislike arthouse films that give the genre a bad name, yet writer-director Ramon Zürcher’s third feature outing regrettably does just that. This pretentious, meandering exercise in allegedly profound cinema falls flat shortly after it begins and never recovers, growing ever more pointless, unfocused and self-important as it unfolds. Set in the rural childhood home of two very different and quietly combative sisters (Maren Eggert, Britta Hammelstein), the film follows the events associated with a birthday celebration involving the siblings and their families. As the festivities (if they can be called that) begin to play out, however, it quickly becomes apparent that this party will go anything but smoothly given its cast of largely reprehensible characters, nearly all of whom utter their hate-filled insults with stoically deadpan monotone delivery. This examination of a seriously troubled family, in turn, increasingly draws heavily from “The Big Book of Domestic Dysfunctional Drama,” with virtually every character possessing a crippling physical and/or psychological disorder, qualities that shape their pervasively ugly demeanors. This hodgepodge of elements is thus employed in a futile attempt to build some type of cohesive narrative, presumably in an effort to depict the descent into madness. But this goal is never adequately realized, thanks in large part to a wealth of superficial, pedestrian dialogue that tries mightily to pass itself off as enigmatically “meaningful” and several preposterous surreal segments that are all show and no substance, sequences that resemble scenes out of “Carrie” (1976) or “Firestarter” (1984) if those films had been directed by Ingmar Bergman. And, no matter how much the filmmaker seeks to cover up these innate weaknesses by embellishing them with stunning still life cinematography, the strains of atmospheric classical music and long, lingering facial close-ups, the overall mix of elements just doesn’t work, growing progressively more muddled, laughable and tedious as this tiresome offering wears on…and on…and on. To make matters worse, though, the film also incorporates some positively repugnant images, such as a young woman slicing up her bloody hand on a cheese grater and a cat being locked into a washing machine that’s subsequently switched on, a shamefully disgusting sequence that’s wholly uncalled for, regardless of how simulated it may have been. It’s beyond me how this disastrous project got the green light to begin with, but this is handily one of the worst films of 2024, one that doesn’t deserve whatever attention and accolades it may erroneously garner.
Read full review
★ 8 / 10
Worthy, even if overdone
dukes-79-520112
Even though the dialog was forced and family members' wounds overplayed, I really appreciated the way the story was told and how the healing was revealed. I…
Even though the dialog was forced and family members' wounds overplayed, I really appreciated the way the story was told and how the healing was revealed. I view the movie not as a realistic portrayal of a troubled family. Rather, I view it as careful storytelling through awkward dialog, fantastical scenes, and emotional rawness. Based on this assessment so far, my inclination is to give it a 7. But the good acting and excellent camera work (e.g., the mirrors in the hallway, reflections in the windows, and other subtleties) push it to an 8.
Read full review
★ 1 / 10
A Pretentious Cinematic Trainwreck
brentsbulletinboard
To be blunt, I really dislike arthouse films that give the genre a bad name, yet writer-director Ramon Zürcher's third feature outing regrettably does just…
To be blunt, I really dislike arthouse films that give the genre a bad name, yet writer-director Ramon Zürcher's third feature outing regrettably does just that. This pretentious, meandering exercise in allegedly profound cinema falls flat shortly after it begins and never recovers, growing ever more pointless, unfocused and self-important as it unfolds. Set in the rural childhood home of two very different and quietly combative sisters (Maren Eggert, Britta Hammelstein), the film follows the events associated with a birthday celebration involving the siblings and their families. As the festivities (if they can be called that) begin to play out, however, it quickly becomes apparent that this party will go anything but smoothly given its cast of largely reprehensible characters, nearly all of whom utter their hate-filled insults with stoically deadpan monotone delivery. This examination of a seriously troubled family, in turn, increasingly draws heavily from "The Big Book of Domestic Dysfunctional Drama," with virtually every character possessing a crippling physical and/or psychological disorder, qualities that shape their pervasively ugly demeanors. This hodgepodge of elements is thus employed in a futile attempt to build some type of cohesive narrative, presumably in an effort to depict the descent into madness. But this goal is never adequately realized, thanks in large part to a wealth of superficial, pedestrian dialogue that tries mightily to pass itself off as enigmatically "meaningful" and several preposterous surreal segments that are all show and no substance. And, no matter how much the filmmaker seeks to cover up these innate weaknesses by embellishing them with stunning still life cinematography, the strains of atmospheric classical music and long, lingering facial close-ups, the overall mix of elements just doesn't work, growing progressively more muddled, laughable and tedious as this tiresome offering wears on...and on...and on. To make matters worse, though, the film also incorporates some positively repugnant images, such as a young woman slicing up her bloody hand on a cheese grater and a cat being locked into a washing machine that's subsequently switched on, a shamefully disgusting sequence that's wholly uncalled for, regardless of how simulated it may have been. It's beyond me how this disastrous project got the green light to begin with, but this is handily one of the worst films of 2024, one that doesn't deserve whatever attention and accolades it may erroneously garner.
Read full review
More reviews on IMDb ↗
♡ Thanks for supporting YTS Supporter badges recognize people who help keep YTS running.
67%
TOMATOMETER
· 21 reviews
67%
AUDIENCE
6.3/10
522
•••
I thank you for this film Best wishes, E